Breaking News
Local News

Settlement negotiations engaged

By Janelle Patterson 3 min read
(Graphic by Janelle Patterson) Interact with history at the bottom of this story.

¯ Marietta City Law Director and opposing legal counsel are engaged in settlement negotiations up until Feb. 18.

¯ If a settlement is not reached before the close of mediation that day, the city has the opportunity to respond to Oriana House/the Woman's Home's brief of jurisdiction before the Ohio Supreme Court.

¯ If a settlement is reached, the brief would be withdrawn.

Marietta City Council was informed Monday of a potential conflict of interest during committee discussions about visioning for the city.

Safety-Service Director Steve Wetz noted the same company name and contact of one Becky Mathis-Stump, who council was discussing, as being a participant in active litigation with the city in the three-year dispute concerning Oriana House and the Woman's Home at 812 Third St.

Tuesday, Stump agreed with council's direction away from a potential conflict of interest but clarified that while her company, Ethos Leadership Group, based in Parkersburg, had once been contracted with the Woman's Home during its transition to closure, the nonprofit does not have an active contract with the firm.

Instead, she now serves as a board member of that nonprofit which still owns the Third Street property and as recently as Jan. 29 and Monday, had served as third-party conveyance of status updates to the board of trustees concerning the litigation.

Marietta City Law Director Paul Bertram also spoke with the Times and City Councilman Geoff Schenkel concerning recent updates in that lawsuit the city pursued in 2019.

Bertram explained that after Oriana House and the Woman's Home lost its suit in September 2019 and filed for an appeal before the Fourth District Court of Appeals, the appeals court moved through its processes in 2020.

That court rendered its judgment in October of last year and sent the case back to the trial court's appointed Judge John M. Solovan.

While in negotiations between legal counsel, Oriana House/Woman's Home have also filed a brief of jurisdiction with the Ohio Supreme Court, appealing the Fourth District's ruling.

Bertram has indicated that the following routes are open depending on whether an agreement can be reached between parties or not.

1. Reach a settlement before Feb. 18: Oriana House counsel would withdraw its brief of jurisdiction before the Ohio Supreme Court.

2. Do not reach a settlement before Feb. 18 mediation meeting but reach an agreement in mediation that day: Oriana House counsel would withdraw its brief of jurisdiction before the Ohio Supreme Court.

In either of the first two scenarios, Bertram has indicated that the expectation as it stood Feb. 1, would be to complete the city ordinance process of appearing before the city's planning commission to receive a special use permit.

By that same indication, it appears to be a formality, not open for legal debate once before the commission.

3. No agreement is reached by the close of mediation: Bertram then has time to file a response to the brief of jurisdiction with the Ohio Supreme Court.

¯ If the OSC accepts jurisdiction: Then the high court would review the arguments made in the appeal.

¯ If the OSC denies jurisdiction: Then the case follows the judgment in the appeals court, returning to Solovan for a hearing.

Neither Marietta attorney Abe Sellers, of Theisen and Brock, nor Oriana House Akron-based attorney Stephen Funk returned multiple requests for comment Tuesday.

How did we get here?

Janelle Patterson may be reached at jpatterson@mariettatimes.com.

Starting at /week.